The Man in Black appears in Dolores' nightmares and memory flashbacks, during their interaction that apparently happened off-screen in The Original. He throws her on the hay in the barn, pulls out a large knife, and suggests they reacquaint themselves. He tells her to "Start at the beginning." When Dolores kills Rebus in the barn, she is seeing the memory of the Man in Black standing in the same spot, and hears a voice say "Kill him" before she shoots Rebus.

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.